![]() This point canīe illustrated by the famous example of the Indian prince who, having Hume's rule of induction, inįact, stultifies scientific inquiry since, on his account, testimonialĮvidence can never overcome a presumptive law of nature. One of the key points stressed by Price is that Hume'sĪccount of inductive reasoning does not fit with the kind of inferences That an event will happen in a future trial, or even render it so muchĪs probable, that it will always happen in all future trials" (pp.Ģ9-30). Greatest uniformity and frequency of experience will not offer a proof, Lawlike behavior is highly probable, but does not warrant the conclusion They argued that uniform experience shows that Who argued, on the basis of the probability calculus, that Hume'sĪrgument is flawed. Greatest attention to the criticisms of Thomas Bayes and Richard Price Locke) and then proceeds to show the weakness of the argument byĭiscussing some of Hume's contemporary critics. Miracle can never outweigh opposing evidence since the laws of natureĪre derived from the constant and uniform testimony of the senses.Įarman first shows that the argument against miracles is unoriginal (forĮxample, Hume owes the general formulation of the problem of miracles to According to Hume, the testimony in favor of a Opposition"-based upon the definition of a miracle as a violation Miracles, including a nice selection of Hume's contemporaryĮarman discusses Hume's claim to provide a "proof"Īgainst miracles-an argument leaving "no room for doubt or Texts providing the context of the eighteenth-century debate over Long as the world endures." Part 2 contains a selection of primary Kinds of superstitious delusion, and consequently, will be useful as Short of Hume's claim to provide "an everlasting check to all Miracles" is mostly unoriginal and, even where original, falls far In part 1 he argues that Hume's essay "Of $39.95 paper, $21.95-John Earman's book is divided into two Hume's Abject Failure: the Argument Against Miracles. Hume's Abject Failure: the Argument Against Miracles." Retrieved from Hume's Abject Failure: the Argument Against Miracles." The Free Library.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |